background

Toxic masculinity: is it a thing of women?

Why can't an heterosexual guy tell a heterosexual guy

That he thinks his booty is fly?

Not all the time, obviously

Just when he's got a problem with his self esteem.


- Flight of the conchords - Bret, you've got it going on

When one speaks of toxic masculinity, one almost immediately thinks of the effect it has on women. In fact, they are the designated victims of a system that allows hateful elements to spread in our society, such as the wage gap for example, or different treatment in the workplace, sexist phrases, double standards in judging sexuality... and we could go on and on. It is almost automatic to think, therefore, that combating male chauvinism, understood as "the adherence to those behaviours and attitudes (personal, social, cultural) by which males in general, or some of them, would express the conviction of their own superiority over women on an intellectual, psychological, biological, etc. level, and would thus seek to justify the position of privilege they occupy in society and history"[1] is something for women, and in particular for feminists. Often, indeed, they themselves believe that it is not the right of men to speak on such matters; because a man, precisely because he is a man, naturally finds himself unable - let alone willing - to fight the system that makes him privileged by birthright. And a man, precisely because he is a man (and not just a man, but Male, White, Straight: or MBEB, where the last letter stands for Basic) and therefore belongs to that category blessed by good fortune to which everything is due, should not have a voice on topics that concern women and their struggle.

On the other hand, isn't the idea that a man, precisely because he is a man, cannot have the desire to question himself sexist? Because if every woman is unique, and if each one deserves recognition as a person even more than as a woman (isn't that so?), then why should 'men' be all the same, a monolithic group of indistinguishable clones to be blamed on principle, to be treated as privileged imbeciles? In fact, one mistake some people who call themselves feminists fall into is that of projecting the stereotypes of which women are victims onto the other sex. If women must all be mothers and angels of the home, then all men must be superficial, emotionally limited, unable to break out of the cage of gender roles...

The reason for this is unfortunately very simple: often, in fact, men prefer not to take a stand on such issues, limiting themselves to thinking that they are not acting in a bad way, that they are different from those who commit violence against women, from those who use sexism as a weapon to defend their fragile security. In fact, it often happens that toxic masculinity - and the fear of facing it, the huge Goliath that seems to overpower any personal initiative - leads men to fall into the paradox of the good man. The good men[2] are all those who would never commit rape. They would never dream of beating up a girl, and far be it from them to send intimate photos of their girlfriends to one of those telegram groups[3] that were so much talked about some time ago. Those are very, very bad things indeed, and no good guy[4] would ever do that. And anyone could be sure of it, because you can't understand how you could not trust someone so good, so honest, so careful.

The fact is that it is not enough to be able to stoically resist the desire to commit violence against a woman in order to be able to think of oneself as a good man: not committing such a crime is hardly enough to be considered a decent person. No one should expect to receive an award, a pat on the back and a handshake for literally just being a person capable of giving respect to others, or even showing some empathy.

Also because drawing dividing lines is quite risky, and this is where the paradox is created: since these are imaginary, those who need to feel like a good man at all costs can move them at will, to consider themselves always different from those they call beasts. And yet, it is not necessary to commit crimes to play into the hands of the sexist culture and make women into dehumanised objects: it is enough to whistle at a girl in the street, or make a sexist joke against her to make your friends laugh, or even just to be the one laughing. Male chauvinist culture is so pervasive that every time you don't fight it, you play into its hands, and no imaginary line can shield us from our responsibilities.

At the end of the day, it is still about personal responsibility, the courage to stand out from the pack (which is a bit like the gender-friendly version of Le Bon's crowd[5]), to oppose those who claim that to be a real man you have to be macho, "have only one thing on your mind", "don't cry like a sissy", be superficial and careless. It is necessary to be self-critical, to discover oneself as a puppet of a system that indicates exactly how to behave in order to remain within one's social category. And then it is necessary to carry out self-analysis, to understand how one really is, how one would like to behave, and what kind of relationship one wishes to establish with other people.

It is therefore necessary to take a position, and to do so forcefully, because indifference is itself a position: those who think it is enough not to take sides are actually taking the side of the strongest, and of a toxic culture that flattens individual differences to make us all stereotypes, men and women prisoners of roles that have little or nothing to do with the freedom to self-determine.

And you, men, whose side are you on?

Translated by Francesca Cioffi

Original version by Simona Sora



[1]https://www.treccani.it/vocabolario/maschilismo/

[2]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OEPsqFLhHBc&ab_channel=TheHollywoodReporter

[3]https://www.wired.it/internet/web/2020/04/03/revenge-porn-network-telegram/

[4] @awardsforgoodboys is enlightening on this issue

[5] https://www.giornalistaletterario.it/recensioni/gustave-le-bon-psicologia-delle-folle-limpeccabile-analisi-psicologica/


Share the post

  • L'Autore

    Simona Sora

    Laurea triennale in Lettere Moderne ad indirizzo storico, laurea magistrale in Antropologia Culturale ed Etnologia. Nel 2014 ha fatto volontariato in un pueblo delle Ande peruviane perché voleva sapere cosa si prova ad essere straniera; nel 2018 ha fatto ritorno sulla stessa catena montuosa, seppur in diversi confini nazionali, per scrivere una tesi sul rapporto tra volontari italiani e campesinos, o forse solo per fare di nuovo ricerca su sé stessa.

    Nella vita ha fatto la receptionist di un ostello in Portogallo, la cameriera a Brescia, la promoter sul lago di Garda, la commessa a Milano, tenendo sempre le orecchie e gli occhi ben aperti su tutto quello che le capitava intorno.

    Da grande vorrebbe continuare ad ascoltare le storie delle persone, per fare esperienza del mondo attraverso i loro occhi; vorrebbe prendere un’altra laurea cambiando completamente ambito o forse discostandosi solo di un po’, perché studiare le piace tanto e le piace anche spaziare tra le conoscenze, e vorrebbe anche scrivere.

    Si sente sempre un essere umano in costruzione.

    In Mondo Internazionale è autrice di pezzi per il progetto TrattaMI Bene e revisore di bozze.

    Bachelor’s Degree in Modern Literature with a major in history, Master Degree in Cultural Anthropology and Ethnology. In 2014 she volunteered in a pueblo in the Peruvian Andes, because she wanted to understand what it is like to be a stranger; in 2018 she returned to the same mountain chain, although in different national borders, in order to write her thesis about the relationship between Italian volunteers and Campesinos, or maybe just to research herself again.

    She worked as a receptionist in a hostel in Portugal, as a waitress in Brescia, as a promoter on Garda lake and as a shopping assistant in Milan, and she have always kept her hears and eyes opened to see all the things around her.

    When she will grow up, she would like to keep listening about people’s stories, to experience the world through their eyes; she would like to pursuit a new degree in something completely new, or maybe in something just a little different from her degrees. She loves studying and learning different subjects too. She would also like writing.

    She always feels herself like a constantly evolving human being. In “Mondo Internazionale” she writes articles about DirittiUmani and she proofreads articles.

You might be interested in

Image

Anti-Semitism spreading across Europe

Rebecca Scaglia
Image

The impact of Brexit on human rights protection

Redazione
Image

The UN Specialised Agencies

Sofia Abourachid
Log in to your Mondo Internazionale account
Forgot Password? Get it back here